Pumpernickel's
Welcome to Pumpernickel's, an inviting German restaurant nestled in the heart of Northport, NY. With its warm atmosphere and authentic culinary offerings, this charming eatery promises a delightful experience that whisk you away to Germany itself.
Pumpernickel's specializes in hearty German cuisine complemented by a selection of continental dishes. The menu is a treasure trove of tantalizing options, starting with appetizing morsels like the Head Cheese with Sauce Vinaigrette ($7.95) and the richly flavored Escargot ($11.95). For those with a zest for seafood, don’t miss the Chilled Shrimp Cocktail ($11.95) or the Baked Chopped Clams ($9.95) — each plate crafted with care and bursting with flavor.
As you settle into your table, you'll feel the ambiance envelop you, reminiscent of a cozy Bavarian tavern — perfect for an intimate dinner or a casual lunch with friends. The friendly staff, including expert waitresses who can navigate the German menu with ease, enhance your dining experience. The owner, Artie, is known to greet patrons warmly, ensuring every visit feels like catching up with a longtime friend.
Among popular main courses, the Wienerschnitzel stands out, delivering a delightful crunch with every bite, a true gem at a great price — a must-try for both newcomers and regulars alike. Try to save room for the dessert; patrons rave about the generous portions and exquisite flavors that often linger in their minds long after the meal.
What truly sets Pumpernickel's apart is the cherished community feeling it cultivates. Just ask long-time customer Mary Margaret, who notes that she and her partner have been enjoying the welcoming atmosphere here for over 20 years. This sentiment is echoed by many who appreciate the personal touches from the attentive service, including the server who remembers their favorite dishes, making each visit feel special and familiar.
Pumpernickel's isn’t just a dining spot; it’s an experience filled with authentic German flavors, friendly service, and a touch of European charm. Whether you're looking for a cozy place to enjoy the delights of Germany or simply crave a beautifully executed meal, this restaurant deserves a spot on your must-visit list. Prost!
- Head Cheese With Sauce VinaigretteUS$7.95
- Ochsenmaul Salad (pickled Sliced Tongue)US$7.95
- Herring In Sour Cream & OnionsUS$8.95
- Long Island Clams On The Half ShellUS$9.95
- Baked Chopped ClamsUS$9.95
- Chilled Shrimp CocktailUS$11.95
- Clams CasinoUS$9.95
- EscargotUS$11.95
- Stuffed Mushroom CapsUS$8.95
- Maryland Crab CakeUS$12.95
- Gravlax, Our Own Cured SalmonUS$11.95
- Bratwurst 1 Piece With SauerkrautUS$9.95
- Frogs Legs FranceseUS$12.95
- Clams OreganatoUS$8.95
- Soup Du JourUS$6.95
- Manhattan Clam ChowderUS$6.95
- French Onion SoupUS$6.95
- Baked French Onion Soup With Melted Swiss CheeseUS$7.95
- House Garden SaladUS$5.95
- Caesar Salad (for Two)US$12.95
- Broiled Salmon With Dill SauceUS$21.95
- Broiled Filet Of Sole With Mashed PotatoUS$20.95
- Fried Filet Of Sole With Tartar Sauce And French FriesUS$20.95
- Fried Genuine Bay Scallops With French Fries
- Broiled Genuine Bay Scallops With Mashed Potato
- Shrimp Scampi Over RiceUS$21.95
- Shrimp A La Maison With Mashed PotatoUS$21.95
- Fried Butterfly Shrimp With Mashed PotatoUS$21.95
- Broiled Butterfly Shrimp With Mashed PotatoUS$21.95
- Fried Seafood Platter (shrimp, Scallops & Sole) With French FriesUS$25.95
- Broiled Imported Lobster Tails With Drawn Butter And French FriesUS$43.95
- Whole Lobster (advanced Notice)
- Our Famous Sauerbraten With Potato Dumplings & Red CabbageUS$19.95
- Hungarian Beef Goulash With Buttered NoodlesUS$19.95
- Wiener Roastbraten With Crisp Onions & BratkartoffelUS$26.95
- Natur Schnitzel, A Sauteed Veal Steak With Fresh Mushrooms And BratkartoffelUS$22.95
- Wiener Schnitzel With BratkartoffelUS$21.95
- A La Holstein With Bratkartoffel (cooked To Order)US$22.95
- Jaeger Schnitzel With BratkartoffelUS$22.95
- Zigeunerbraten (filet Mignon Gypsy Style) With BratkartoffelUS$34.95
- Beef Rouladen With DumplingsUS$19.95
- Bratwurst, KnockwurstUS$18.95
- Kassler Rippchen, Smoked Loin Of PorkUS$19.95
- Pigs Knuckle With Sauerkraut And Mashed PotatoUS$20.95
- Homemade Frikadellen With Fresh Mushroom Gravy And Mashed PotatoUS$18.95
- Veal Cordon BleuUS$23.95
- Pork Chops (chef's Style Or Broiled) With Mashed PotatoUS$19.95
- Filet Of Beef A La Stroganoff With NoodlesqUS$23.95
- Roast Loin Of Pork With Mashed PotatoUS$19.95
- Veal Francese With Mashed PotatoUS$22.95
- New York Cut Sirloin Steak And French FriesUS$31.95
- Steak Au Poivre, Butterflied Filet Mignon With Mashed PotatoUS$34.95
- Filet Mignon Of Prime Beef With French FriesUS$33.95
- Chopped Sirloin SteakUS$18.95
- Calves Liver Saute With Bacon & OnionsUS$20.95
- Herb Roasted Rack Of Lamb With Mashed PotatoUS$32.95
- Surf & Turf With French FriesUS$40.95
- One Half Roasted Long Island Duckling With Apple Sauce & DumplingsUS$20.95
- Chicken A La Maison With Mashed PotatoUS$19.95
- Chicken Cordon BleuUS$19.95
- Chicken Francese With Mashed PotatoUS$19.95
- Half A Roasted Chicken With Mashed PotatoUS$18.95
- Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken Breast (grilled Shrimp $6.95 Extra)US$18.95
- Vegetarian PlatterUS$16.95
- Chicken A La Joe With Chicken Cutlet, Mozzarella, SpinachUS$21.95
- Vegetable, Mashed PotatoUS$4.00
- Potato DumplingsUS$5.00
368 Reviews
18 Sep 2025
28 Jul 2025
20 Jul 2025
28 Jun 2025
04 Jun 2025
Bibo's NY Pizza
Handsome Hog
Devil's Reef
Chocobar Creamery
PIZZANISTA! San Marino
Join the Pumpernickel's Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.